-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 150
Open
Description
Description
Currently, Music Blocks v4 lacks comprehensive input validation and error handling for block parameters. When users enter invalid data (such as negative tempo values, out-of-range pitch values, invalid note names, or malformed duration values), the system either fails silently or crashes without providing helpful feedback.
This issue proposes implementing a robust parameter validation system with user-friendly error messages to improve user experience and make debugging easier for music programming learners.
Problem Statement
- Users don't receive feedback when entering invalid block parameters
- Silent failures make it hard to identify where mistakes occur
- No suggestions are provided for valid input ranges or formats
- Errors are not standardized across different block types
Proposed Solution
Implement a comprehensive validation system with the following components:
1. Validation Layer (TypeScript utility functions)
- Create
/app/lib/validation.tswith validation functions for common parameters - Define validation schemas for each block type
- Support different validation rules:
- Range validation: tempo (10-500 BPM), pitch (0-127), volume (0-100)
- Format validation: note names (C, D, E, F, G, A, B with octaves), durations
- Type validation: ensure numeric vs. string inputs
2. Error Message Component (React)
- Create reusable error message component in
/app/components/ - Display clear, actionable error messages
- Show valid input ranges and examples
- Allow inline error display in block parameter fields
3. Validation Integration
- Add validation hooks to block parameter input components
- Validate on blur and onChange events
- Prevent invalid values from being submitted to the engine
- Show validation status with visual feedback (red border, error icon)
Example Implementation for Tempo Block
// Example error messages:
// ❌ "Tempo must be between 10 and 500 BPM. You entered: -50"
// ✓ "Valid tempo value: 120 BPM"Key Files to Modify/Create
/app/lib/validation.ts(new)/app/components/ValidationError.tsx(new)/app/components/blocks/(existing block components - to integrate validation)/app/lib/__tests__/validation.test.ts(new unit tests)/app/types/validation.types.ts(new - for validation schema types)
Metadata
Metadata
Assignees
Labels
No labels