Skip to content

feat(blocks): Add input validation and user-friendly error messages for block parameters #468

@Ruthwik000

Description

@Ruthwik000

Description

Currently, Music Blocks v4 lacks comprehensive input validation and error handling for block parameters. When users enter invalid data (such as negative tempo values, out-of-range pitch values, invalid note names, or malformed duration values), the system either fails silently or crashes without providing helpful feedback.

This issue proposes implementing a robust parameter validation system with user-friendly error messages to improve user experience and make debugging easier for music programming learners.

Problem Statement

  • Users don't receive feedback when entering invalid block parameters
  • Silent failures make it hard to identify where mistakes occur
  • No suggestions are provided for valid input ranges or formats
  • Errors are not standardized across different block types

Proposed Solution

Implement a comprehensive validation system with the following components:

1. Validation Layer (TypeScript utility functions)

  • Create /app/lib/validation.ts with validation functions for common parameters
  • Define validation schemas for each block type
  • Support different validation rules:
    • Range validation: tempo (10-500 BPM), pitch (0-127), volume (0-100)
    • Format validation: note names (C, D, E, F, G, A, B with octaves), durations
    • Type validation: ensure numeric vs. string inputs

2. Error Message Component (React)

  • Create reusable error message component in /app/components/
  • Display clear, actionable error messages
  • Show valid input ranges and examples
  • Allow inline error display in block parameter fields

3. Validation Integration

  • Add validation hooks to block parameter input components
  • Validate on blur and onChange events
  • Prevent invalid values from being submitted to the engine
  • Show validation status with visual feedback (red border, error icon)

Example Implementation for Tempo Block

// Example error messages:
// ❌ "Tempo must be between 10 and 500 BPM. You entered: -50"
// ✓ "Valid tempo value: 120 BPM"

Key Files to Modify/Create

  • /app/lib/validation.ts (new)
  • /app/components/ValidationError.tsx (new)
  • /app/components/blocks/ (existing block components - to integrate validation)
  • /app/lib/__tests__/validation.test.ts (new unit tests)
  • /app/types/validation.types.ts (new - for validation schema types)

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions